Skip to content
Blurbay

Substack vs ConvertKit for Content Monetization

In today’s digital landscape, content creators, whether they’re social media influencers or everyday individuals looking to monetize their passion, face a crucial decision: choosing the right platform to manage and grow their newsletter. This comprehensive guide compares Substack and ConvertKit, two leading contenders in the newsletter management space, to help you determine which aligns best with your content monetization goals.

Content creator setting up a video production workspace to monetize digital content

Monetization Models and Pricing

The pricing structures of Substack and ConvertKit represent fundamentally different approaches to content monetization:

Close-up of hands holding coins illustrating revenue sharing and monetization concepts

  • Substack operates on a revenue-sharing model. It’s free to use upfront, but takes a 10% cut of your subscription revenue. This model is particularly appealing for newcomers or those with smaller audiences. For instance, if your newsletter generates $3,000 in monthly subscriptions, Substack’s fee would be $300. While this approach eliminates upfront costs, it’s worth noting that as your subscriber base grows, so do the fees. This Substack vs ConvertKit analysis by Feather provides a deeper dive into the implications of this model.

  • ConvertKit, on the other hand, uses a tiered pricing structure. Plans start at approximately $25 per month for the Creator Plan and increase based on your subscriber count. The key advantage here is that you retain 100% of your earnings. This model becomes increasingly cost-effective as your audience grows, especially if you’re leveraging advanced monetization strategies beyond simple subscriptions.

To illustrate, let’s consider a hypothetical creator with 1,000 subscribers paying $5 each per month:

  • On Substack: Monthly revenue would be $5,000, with $500 going to Substack as fees.
  • On ConvertKit: Assuming a $49/month plan, the creator would pay $49 in platform fees, keeping $4,951 of the $5,000 revenue.

This example underscores how the choice between these platforms can significantly impact your bottom line as your audience scales.

Core Features and Content Creation

Both platforms offer distinct advantages when it comes to managing and monetizing your newsletter:

Substack

  • Ease of Use: Substack’s interface is designed with simplicity in mind. Its clean, minimalist approach allows creators to focus on writing and publishing without getting bogged down in technical complexities. This is particularly beneficial for writers who want to concentrate on content creation rather than platform management.

  • Integrated Community: Substack’s built-in discovery tools, such as Notes and comment sections, facilitate community building around your content. This feature is especially valuable for hobby writers and emerging influencers looking to foster engagement and loyalty among their readers.

  • Basic Customization: While Substack keeps things simple, it offers limited customization options. This means your newsletter might have a uniform look across the board, which can be a double-edged sword. On one hand, it ensures a clean, professional appearance with minimal effort. On the other, it may limit your ability to stand out visually in a crowded market.

ConvertKit

  • Advanced Automation: ConvertKit excels in sophisticated automation tools, segmentation, and personalized workflows. This is ideal for influencers and professional marketers who want granular control over email sequences and audience engagement. For example, you could create a series of welcome emails that adapt based on a subscriber’s interests or behavior.

  • Customization and Integrations: With advanced features for landing pages, customizable templates, and integrations with third-party tools, ConvertKit provides the flexibility to create a newsletter that aligns perfectly with your brand identity. This level of customization is crucial for creators who see their newsletter as an extension of their overall brand strategy.

  • Diverse Monetization Options: Beyond paid memberships, ConvertKit supports digital product sales, sponsorships, and affiliate marketing. This makes it a robust choice for those treating their newsletter as a full-scale business. For instance, you could sell an e-book directly through your newsletter or seamlessly integrate affiliate links into your content.

For an in-depth review of these features and how they stack up in real-world scenarios, check out Landon Poburan’s breakdown on the strengths and limitations of each platform.

Audience Growth and SEO Capabilities

Audience Growth

  • Substack leverages built-in discovery tools to help you reach new readers. Its social features, like the ability to recommend other newsletters, can aid in organic audience growth. This is particularly effective if your content resonates strongly with a niche audience, as it can spread through word-of-mouth within the Substack ecosystem.

  • ConvertKit requires more proactive strategies to drive traffic, even though it offers integrations with landing pages and referral programs. However, its robust automation and segmentation capabilities can be a major boon once you have established an audience. For example, you could create targeted campaigns based on subscriber behavior, increasing engagement and retention rates.

SEO Considerations

  • Substack includes useful SEO features such as custom domains, meta descriptions, XML sitemaps, and schema markup. However, in practice, many creators find that it doesn’t always translate to meaningful search engine visibility. This is partly due to the nature of newsletter content, which isn’t always optimized for search engines.

  • ConvertKit isn’t primarily built as a blogging tool, so its SEO features are less comprehensive. If SEO is a top priority, you might need to pair it with a dedicated website or blog platform. This could involve using ConvertKit for email management while hosting your main content on a more SEO-friendly platform like WordPress.

Which Platform Is Best For You?

Choosing between Substack and ConvertKit ultimately depends on your goals, current audience size, and long-term content strategy:

  • For beginners and hobbyists, Substack’s free model and simplicity can get you started quickly without financial risk. It’s particularly suited for writers who want to focus on content before worrying too much about technical details. If you’re just starting out and want to test the waters of newsletter publishing, Substack provides an accessible entry point.

  • For influencers and professional marketers, ConvertKit’s advanced features, automation capabilities, and diverse monetization options make it worth the investment as your audience grows and your content strategy becomes more complex. If you’re looking to create sophisticated marketing funnels or sell a variety of digital products alongside your newsletter, ConvertKit offers the tools to support these ambitions.

Why Consider Blurbay?

While both Substack and ConvertKit have their merits, many creators are now looking for platforms that combine robust monetization tools with greater flexibility. That’s where Blurbay comes in.

Blurbay offers a comprehensive solution for managing not just newsletters, but also online courses, videos, e-books, and live events. Here’s why you might consider switching to Blurbay:

Professional handshake symbolizing a strategic partnership and innovative content monetization platform transition to Blurbay

  • All-in-One Monetization: Create your own premium page where you can offer subscriptions, sell digital products, host courses, and even run live events. This means you’re not limited to just newslettersyour entire content ecosystem can be monetized in one place.

  • Subscription & Community Building: Build engaging communities on Blurbay, with integrated group chats managed via Telegram. This feature offers a more interactive and enjoyable experience for your subscribers, fostering a sense of belonging and increasing retention rates.

  • Flexible Sales Options: Whether you’re selling short videos, extensive online courses, or downloadable e-books, Blurbay lets you set up and manage these digital assets effortlessly. This versatility is particularly valuable for creators who want to diversify their income streams beyond traditional newsletter subscriptions.

  • Enhanced Customization and Ownership: With Blurbay, you maintain full control over your page’s appearance and content, ensuring that your brand stands out without unwanted third-party branding or restrictions. This level of customization allows you to create a unique experience for your audience, reinforcing your personal brand.

If you’re looking for a platform that extends well beyond traditional newsletter management, Blurbay might be the perfect fit. To learn more about Blurbay’s unique features, check out our posts on becoming a best online nutrition coach for similar success stories, or explore comparisons like buymeacoffee vs onlyfans to see how other digital monetization tools measure up.

Final Thoughts

Both Substack and ConvertKit offer valuable tools for monetizing your content, but the best choice depends on your specific needs and audience size. Substack’s simplicity and free model make it ideal for beginners and hobbyists, while ConvertKit’s advanced features cater to established influencers who need more nuanced engagement and automation capabilities.

For creators looking to expand beyond email newsletters and want to harness a full suite of monetization tools, Blurbay offers a compelling alternative. By combining subscriptions, digital product sales, online courses, and community management in one platform, Blurbay empowers you to build and grow your personal brand from one central hub.

As you evaluate these options, consider your long-term goals, the type of content you create, and how you envision your relationship with your audience evolving. Remember, the platform you choose should not only meet your current needs but also provide room for growth and experimentation as your content strategy develops.

Choose the tool that aligns with your vision, and keep exploring ways to turn your digital content into a thriving business. Whether you opt for the simplicity of Substack, the advanced features of ConvertKit, or the comprehensive approach of Blurbay, the key is to focus on creating value for your audience and consistently delivering content that resonates with them.