Substack vs Ghost: A Comparison for Content Creators

In the digital age, content creators face a crucial decision when choosing a platform to share and monetize their work. Social media influencers and creative entrepreneurs need clarity on which solution best suits their unique needs. This comprehensive comparison breaks down the key differences between Substack and Ghost, two popular publishing platforms, and explains how integrating additional tools like BlurBay can help expand your monetization strategy with online courses, videos, and digital goods.

Overview

Both Substack and Ghost cater to writers and content creators, but they offer distinct benefits:

• Substack is designed for simplicity. It’s perfect for creators who want a quick setup and access to a built-in audience within the Substack ecosystem.
• Ghost is a powerful, open-source platform that emphasizes complete ownership, customization, and advanced functionality. It appeals to creators who want full control over their brand and revenue streams.

Ownership and Revenue Models

Ghost: Total Revenue Retention

Ghost stands out by charging a flat hosting fee with 0% transaction fees. This means that once you cover your hosting costs (for example, $348/year for up to 1,000 subscribers), you keep 100% of your earnings. This model makes Ghost a compelling choice for creators looking to maximize long-term revenue.

For instance, if you have 1,000 subscribers paying $5 per month, your annual revenue would be $60,000. With Ghost, you’d keep $59,652 after hosting fees, compared to $54,000 with Substack (which takes a 10% cut). This difference becomes even more significant as your subscriber base grows. For more detailed insights on revenue differences, check out this discussion on Ghost vs Substack.

Substack: Built-In Audience with a Cost

Substack simplifies the process by charging 10% of your subscription revenue along with standard Stripe processing fees. Although it offers immediate access to a built-in audience through its cross-promotion features, the cost may add up as your subscriber base grows.

For example, a creator with 5,000 subscribers paying $10 per month would generate $600,000 annually. Substack’s 10% fee would amount to $60,000 per year, a significant sum that could be reinvested in your business if you were using a platform like Ghost.

If you’re considering the trade-offs between immediate ease of use and long-term earnings, you might also be interested in reading about Substack vs ConvertKit, another popular email marketing tool.

Customization and Flexibility

Full Control with Ghost

With Ghost, creators can fully customize the look and functionality of their sites. From unique themes and custom domains to integrations with tools like Zapier and Google AdSense, Ghost gives you the freedom to build a truly branded experience.

For example, you could create a sleek, minimalist design for a tech newsletter or a vibrant, image-rich layout for a food blog. This level of control is ideal for those who want to differentiate their presence in a competitive digital landscape.

Simplicity with Substack

Substack, by contrast, offers a simpler setup with limited customization options. The platform focuses on getting your content out quickly with basic branding elements such as fonts and colors, and emails are sent from an @substack.com address.

While this can work well if you prioritize ease of use over design flexibility, it may limit your ability to stand out in a crowded market. For instance, a financial advisor publishing investment advice might find it challenging to convey professionalism and uniqueness within Substack’s constraints.

Ease of Use versus Advanced Functionality

• Substack is perfect for non-technical users. Its streamlined approach means you can start publishing without dealing with technical configurations. You could have your first newsletter out within an hour of signing up.

• Ghost Pro offers a 14-day free trial for its hosted solution, while the self-hosted version requires some technical expertise. However, this investment pays off by giving you robust control over your content and site architecture. For example, you could integrate advanced analytics tools or create custom membership tiers with Ghost’s flexibility.

Community and Promotion Tools

Substack’s Built-In Promotion

Substack comes with integrated cross-promotion features, meaning your content can benefit from exposure within its ecosystem. For instance, if you write about climate change, your posts might be recommended to readers of other environmental newsletters on the platform.

However, the trade-off is that audience engagement remains largely on the Substack platform, limiting your ability to build a community on your own terms.

Leveraging Ghost for External Promotion

While Ghost does not offer native community features, it empowers you to integrate third-party tools to engage your audience. This approach allows you to build independent channels for promotion and interaction, ensuring that you retain full control over your subscriber relationships.

For example, you could use Ghost in combination with a Discord server for community discussions, or integrate with social media platforms for wider reach. This flexibility allows you to create a tailored ecosystem for your brand.

BlurBay: Complementing Your Monetization Strategy

For content creators looking to diversify income beyond subscriptions or newsletters, BlurBay offers a suite of monetization tools including:

• Selling Online Courses and Videos: Package multiple lessons or video tutorials into a course. With features that enable time-gated releases or bundled content, you can design learning experiences that keep your audience coming back. For instance, a fitness influencer could create a 30-day workout program with daily video releases.

• Digital Goods and Files: Whether it’s an eBook, templates, or exclusive digital downloads, BlurBay allows you to sell these assets directly to your followers. A graphic designer, for example, could offer premium Photoshop brushes or InDesign templates.

• Paid Communities: Seamlessly create membership tiers and offer access to exclusive communities. These communities can be managed on platforms like Telegram, offering a more intimate way to interact with your audience. A business coach might use this feature to create a mastermind group for entrepreneurs.

By combining Ghost or Substack for your written content with BlurBay’s monetization tools, you create a winning strategy that leverages the strengths of each platform. This multi-platform approach allows you to cater to different segments of your audience with varied content types and pricing models.

For more insights on multi-platform strategies, you might find it helpful to explore comparisons like Buy Me a Coffee vs OnlyFans or Ko-fi vs Patreon, which discuss different ways to monetize your content and engage with your audience.

Which Platform is Right for You?

Choosing between Substack and Ghost depends on your priorities as a creator:

• If you value ease of use and prefer to tap into an existing network with minimal setup, Substack might be your platform of choice. It’s particularly suitable for writers who are just starting out or those who don’t want to deal with technical aspects of website management.

• If you prioritize total revenue retention, customization, and full ownership of your content, then Ghost is the better option. It’s ideal for established creators who want to build a unique brand and have complete control over their digital presence.

No matter which primary platform you select, integrating BlurBay into your strategy can help you expand your revenue streams by offering online courses, videos, community memberships, and digital goods.

---

For more tips on expanding your monetization strategies, you may also want to learn about how to become a best online nutrition coach or explore comparisons such as Substack vs WordPress. Each of these resources offers insights to help you make informed decisions tailored to your creative business needs.

Remember, the key to success in the digital content world is not just about choosing the right platform, but also about consistently delivering value to your audience and diversifying your income streams. By carefully considering your options and leveraging the strengths of different tools, you can create a robust and sustainable content business.